rigorous

We are already looking into that: https://github.com/robertjakob/rigorous/tree/main/Agent2_Out... Would be great to see contributions from the community!

...or run it themselves. The code is open source: https://github.com/robertjakob/rigorous Note: The current version uses the OpenAI API, but it should be adaptable to run on local models instead.

No worries, I appreciate that you took the time to read and respond! When I first read "Originality and Contribution" at [1], I actually assumed it was a plagiarism check. It did not occur to me until now that you were referring to novelty with that. Similarly, I assumed "Impact and Significance" referred to more about whether the subject was appropriate for a given journal or not (would readers of this journal find this information significant/relevant/impactful or should it be published elsewhere?). That's a question that many journals do ask of referees, independent of overall novelty, but I see how you mean a different aspect of novelty instead. I'm not opposed to testing your system with a manuscript of my own, but currently the one manuscript that I have approaching publication is still in the internal review stage at my national