STstaltz·Apr 3, 2015
Presentation author here. I didn't publish this to HN myself, it was just discovered by someone among my repos.
Some important things I want to make clear:
1. React is revolutionary. I really like the core idea inside it, which is basically just this
https://joshaber.github.io/2015/01/30/why-react-native-matte...
2. Apart from the core ideas, the surfacing API has its problems: synchronous render (a problem for server-side rendering https://github.com/andreypopp/react-async), mutable API (setState) etc, and most of my presentation. I've spoken to others in the industry (would not like to mention names, but top experts anyway), and they both love React and agree it is contaminated with a bit of bad API.
3. React probably doesn't have the perfect API for the "UIs as pure function of state" approach. It can be improved https://github.com/fa
Read the rest
cebook/react/issues/3398 and https://twitter.com/sebmarkbage/status/543660526908088320
4. This presentation was given at a small meetup and I made it provocative on purpose just to have some fun with friends. The type of stuff you talk about in a small circle, not meant to publish on HN for the whole world https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9QObt0SGriI
5. Cycle.js is not _better_ than React, it is my personal ongoing exploration in how to make React (or React's ideas) better. It is work in progress, and I'm breaking it apart whenever I find a better way of doing stuff. E.g. https://github.com/staltz/cycle/issues/99
6. Cycle.js is not an antagonist to React. I am currently experimenting with Cycle.js + React Native. https://github.com/staltz/cycle/issues/91 If React's API would be a bit less restrictive, I would use it for the web too. But virtual-dom by MattEsch is lighter and less restrictive, so I use that.
7. Don't be so harsh on HN as if I would be intentionally shouting to the whole world that React sucks.