gh-stack

> For example, merging an entire stack is completely broken in many cases: https://github.com/github/gh-stack/discussions/212 > You can merge one by one, but if you're using squash and merge, you need a re-approval for each PR in the stack if you require reviews. This makes you lose out on arguably the biggest gain of stacked PRs. I'm struggling to imagine what it offers at all if that doesn't work! Is it just a way of manually marking another MR as a dependency in the UI so that it shows up with a red X if the other one isn't merged yet?

I've been using the preview for a bit, and I'm quite surprised to see them expanding the preview with so many unfixed issue. For example, merging an entire stack is completely broken in many cases: https://github.com/github/gh-stack/discussions/212 You can merge one by one, but if you're using squash and merge, you need a re-approval for each PR in the stack if you require reviews. This makes you lose out on arguably the biggest gain of stacked PRs. The command line tooling (gh stack) helps to make things slightly less manual, but you still need to be very aware of how git rebase works, the tooling just helps automate it across multiple branches. For example, just running the "gh stack rebase" commands that the UI suggests won't work if your local branches are not in sync with the remote ones, and the tooling won't point that out to you.