HNhnlmorg·Oct 6, 2019
Coincidentally just this week I've working to resolve point 1 in my own shell (https://github.com/lmorg/murex). The compromise I came up with was:
- The shell would attempt to return all suggestions immediately
- However a subset of functions which are known to be slower queries (like recursive directory look ups on larger file system hierarchies) are given a "soft timeout" -- where after that timeout is reached, the slower faster subset of functions are returned as the suggestions while the slower subset continues to run in the background
- The slower subset are also given a "hard timeout" where when that point is reached, if the function still hasn't completed then it is just killed. Any results is has produced (if any) by that point are appended to the auto-completion suggestions.
- If the slower subset finished before the hard timeout
Read the rest
then it is appended to the suggestions. If it finishes before the soft timeout then it's just part of the suggestions.
At the moment it's only been implemented for file and directory suggestions. The fast function is just any files and directories in the current directory level; where as the slow function will return a larger directory hierarchy (for quick navigating akin to fzf). But the plan is to extend it further to support other dynamic completers as well.
This wouldn't completely solve your point though. If the "fast" query actually runs slow (eg you're trying to complete when inside a network mounted filesystem when the network is dropping) then the shell would still hang. At some point I'll add timeouts on them as well. But I am inching towards that goal.
Be warned though, because this feature is less than a week old, it's still only in a feature branch. :)
Your point on 3 is apt too. One of the things I built early on was man page parsing for auto-completion suggestions. I've since learned that I'm not alone in that regard either (Fish does it as well -- and from some of the demo's I've watched it looks like they've done a nicer job there too).
More recently I've also been writing tools that parse binaries for flags as well (in instances where you download a statically compiled binary - eg terraform - and thus don't have any corresponding man pages). That work is very much in it's infancy though.