appengine-clj

On your development server using the GAE jars, however, you can do it (see http://www.hackers-with-attitude.com/2009/08/intertactive-pr... for some guidance). There is nothing like being a C-c C-c away from updating your development server app :) I can't emphasize enough taking the time to get Slime, your GAE development server, lein, and Clojure well-integrated. Your development cycle will make good ol' Java GAE development using the Eclipse plug-in (which I used to think was pretty sweet) feel really really clunky. (See also http://elhumidor.blogspot.com/2009/04/clojure-on-google-appe... for some pointers on setting up Clojure on GAE) (3) GAE's datastore works extremely well with Clojure because it's schema-less. You can store arbitrary hashmaps and structmaps in GAE with zero effort -- it's a match made in heaven. There are a couple of branches of appengine-clj (http://github.com/duelinmarkers/appengine-clj is the original, http://github.com/r0man/appengine-clj is a pretty good branch) that you can look at to get a feel what I mean. (4) With GAE's transaction support and automatic index generation (it's good enough most of the time), you can dynamically create types (kinds), put them in the datastore, and query on them without having to do any of the traditional NoSQL stuff (thinking queries first, denormalizing ahead of time, etc.). It's very sweet. I've done some Clojure+Cassandra and Clojure+GAE is a lot more painless (as long as you can live with the other limitations of the GAE) -- although things are getting much easier in Cassandra world with Hector + automatic index generators. (5) In terms of performance and robustness, nothing about Clojure's held me up. But since I haven't launched yet, that doesn't mean anything. I don't know of any "high-traffic" Clojure+GAE apps out there -- if there are any, I'd love to get some numbers on costs (CPU, especially) to see if there is a significant difference with similar java projects. (Actually, the guys behind https://the-deadline.appspot.com, see http://www.slideshare.net/smartrevolution/how-a-clojure-pet-..., just launched three days ago -- you may want to shoot them an email, they seem nice enough) My guess is that this is a non-issue. Clojure holds up really well against Java and JVM languages like Scala in terms of performance (especially if you give type-hints), and I'd expect the same thing to be true on GAE. (6) General Clojure limitation with web development: Clojure web frameworks are light. You don't get to start with anything as nice as Scala's Lift. You'll have to work and build your own tools -- the good thing is that Clojure is a blast and macros will, in the longer term, allow you to do much cooler stuff. Compojure is a great light framework to start with. Also look at Enlive for templating. On the flip-side Clojure immutable nature works very naturally with request / response. (7) For the OP: before you get on GAE, spend some time reading about its limitations: - exploding indexes (makes implementing text search very tough -- there is some irony in there I think) - no threads (it kills me, I want to use pmap) - not real message queues. GAE is a pull/request-based system, not a push system. It is, however, getting much better (tasks, comet on the coming features list). Still, if you are building a real-time system that needs constant background processing, I'd think twice right now. - if GAE goes down, you're down until they fix things, and will be totally helpless. - some of the GAE goodness/crack means you're locked in (e.g., index building -- to move away you'll have to build equivalent facilities for whatever DB you move to). Although you can protect yourself by being smart in how you abstract away the GAE. (8) Can't think of anything else. If there is interest, I have been thinking about writing some blog posts about my experience setting up a Clojure+GAE development environment, working with the data store, working the the GAE API, etc. Let me know here and I'll get a first post out of the way by week's end.